Quick Facts
- Preppy style enthusiasts
- East Coast fashion shoppers
- College students seeking alternatives to Vineyard Vines
- Southern Tide offers sportier, collegiate style with 'brrrº' cooling technology - polos at $85
- Brooks Brothers is the oldest US men's clothier (1818) for transitioning to corporate preppy
- L.L. Bean focuses on functional outdoor preppy with legendary Bean Boots and excellent return policy
- Sperry remains the undisputed choice for boat shoes with heritage dating to 1935
For preppy style alternatives to Vineyard Vines, Southern Tide offers the closest Southern-inflected rival, while Brooks Brothers and J. Crew provide paths to more sophisticated or versatile wardrobes. L.L. Bean is ideal for rugged outdoor aesthetics.
We all know the smiling pink whale. It’s a staple of the East Coast aesthetic, a symbol of the good life, and a fixture on college campuses. But relying on a single brand to define your wardrobe is a rookie mistake. True style is about curation, not wearing a uniform.
Whether you’re looking to dodge the steep price tags, find a slightly more rugged look, or simply want to stop twinning with everyone at the country club, you have options. We’ve audited the preppy landscape for late 2025 to bring you the brands that actually matter right now. Some are heritage legends; others are modern challengers. Here is where you should be looking.
10 Brands Like Vineyard Vines (Ranked & Reviewed)
Before we dive into the alternatives, let’s look at the benchmark. This pullover is the standard bearer for the category.
NEW, INCREDIBLY SOFT FABRIC The best just got better. This 1/4-zip pullover for men features our new, incredibly soft fabric with moisture wicking, wrinkle resistance and a subtle stripe.
1. Southern Tide
If Vineyard Vines is the king of the New England coast, Southern Tide is the ruler of the Southern tailgate. Founded in 2006 by Allen Stephenson after a stint in Italy, the brand was built on the idea of perfecting the polo shirt.
The Vibe: It’s younger, sportier, and arguably more collegiate than Vineyard Vines. The “Skipjack” emblem is the direct rival to the whale.
The Pricing Reality: Don’t expect a bargain bin here. Quality costs money. As of December 2025, their flagship Skipjack Polo sits at $85.00. Basic tees start around $38.00, while their performance pants will run you roughly $135.00. It’s premium pricing, but the “brrrº” cooling technology in their fabrics makes it worth the investment for hot climates.
2. Sperry
You can’t wear the clothes without the shoes. Paul Sperry invented the boat shoe in 1935 after watching his dog run across ice without slipping. That inspiration led to the razor siped sole that is now industry standard.
The Update: The brand has gone through major changes recently. As of 2024, Sperry is owned by Authentic Brands Group (ABG), having been acquired for roughly $130 million. What does this mean for you? A renewed focus on their core heritage. While they offer apparel, stick to Sperry for what they do best: the Gold Cup boat shoes. They remain the undisputed anchor of any preppy wardrobe.
3. Brooks Brothers
If you want to graduate from “frat preppy” to “corporate preppy,” you go to Brooks Brothers. Established in 1818, they are the oldest men’s clothier in the United States. They didn’t just adopt the style; they invented itintroducing the ready to-wear suit, the button down collar, and the madras pattern to American men.
The Inside Scoop: The business side has stabilized significantly. Entering 2025, the brand is under the umbrella of Catalyst Brands (a massive joint venture involving JCPenney and SPARC Group). While the ownership structure is corporate, the quality of their non iron dress shirts remains a staple for anyone entering the workforce.
4. L. L. Bean
Vineyard Vines is for the boat; L. L. Bean is for the cabin. Based in Freeport, Maine, this is functional New England style at its peak. While Vineyard Vines focuses on the “leisure” aspect of the outdoors, L. L. Bean focuses on the “work” aspect.
Their Bean Boots are legendary for a reason. If your preppy style leans more towards flannel and firewood than gin and tonics, this is your pivot. Plus, their return policy and customer service are still among the best in the retail game.
5. J. Crew
J. Crew occupies the sweet spot between high fashion and accessibility. Under the leadership of CEO Libby Wadle, the brand has successfully modernized its image while keeping the headquarters firmly rooted in New York.
Why Switch? Variety. Vineyard Vines has a very specific color palette (pastels and brights). J. Crew offers a broader range of textures, from their famous Ludlow suits to their broken in tees. It’s less about a logo on the chest and more about the cut of the fabric.
6. Gap
Don’t sleep on the basics. Gap Inc. is a behemoth for a reason, reporting over $15 billion in revenue for the fiscal year ending early 2025. Why does that matter to you? Scale.
Because they produce at such high volume, you can often find 100% cotton chinos and organic tees for a fraction of the price of boutique preppy brands. If you are looking to build the foundation of a wardrobejeans, plain tees, simple button downswithout the branding surcharge, Gap is still the heavyweight champion.
7. Lands’ End
Lands’ End is the unsung hero of practical apparel. While they operate around 26 stores in the US, their digital game is strong globally. They don’t have physical stores in Germany or France, but they run dedicated e-commerce operations there with full shipping capabilities.
The Hidden Gem: Their customization. Lands’ End offers some of the best monogramming services in the market. If you want that personalized “yacht club” look on a tote bag or a fleece without paying luxury prices, this is your go-to.
8. Banana Republic
Also owned by Gap Inc., Banana Republic is the sophisticated older sibling. While Vineyard Vines is perfect for the weekend BBQ, Banana Republic is what you wear to the client meeting on Monday.
They have moved heavily into “quiet luxury” territory recently, focusing on high-quality linens, cashmere, and tailored fits. If you feel like you’ve aged out of the bright pinks and whales, Banana Republic provides a smoother, more neutral transition.
9. Southern Proper
Authenticity is the currency here. Southern Proper prides itself on being “The Original Southern Style Brand.” While they initially gained fame for their bow ties, they have evolved significantly.
Correction: Contrary to older reports, the women’s line is very much alive. As of late 2025, they are actively selling a trendy women’s line through major retailers like Dillard’s and their own site. Their “Belles and Beaus” ambassador program proves they are fully committed to both sides of the aisle. It’s a great boutique alternative if you want to support a brand with a smaller, tighter community feel.
10. Tommy Bahama
Rounding out our list is the king of relaxation. Tommy Bahama is owned by Oxford Industries (who also own Lilly Pulitzer, keeping it all in the family).
Many people mistake this for a “dad brand,” but their quality is undeniable. Their silk camp shirts are legendary, and their linens are perfect for humid climates where heavier cottons fail. Price wise, they sit right alongside Vineyard Vines. You aren’t saving money here, but you are buying into a specific “island life” mindset that is hard to replicate.
